Three Connected Bulbs: A Quick Comparison

Sep 3, 2014 by

The price of connected light bulbs has dropped considerably over the last year. When we reported the availability of INSTEON’s first generation LED bulb a while back, we might not have guessed that the major lighting companies like Philips, TCP, and GE would all have connected bulbs of their own for sale in your local home improvement store. But that’s exactly what’s happened.

This is a quick comparison of the latest wave of connected LED bulbs. All of these bulbs require the use of a hub controller (meaning you can’t just buy the bulb alone and control it from your phone without some sort of controller in your home), and each conforms to the form factor of a standard, medium-base (A19) bulb. Though some of the lines offer bulbs of different color temperatures and brightness, the products we tested were all 60W equivalent, warm white (2700K) bulbs. All of these bulbs are rated for a 22.8 year life, though that calculation is made assuming just 3 hours of use a day (a standard, though somewhat unrealistic, factor in light bulb ratings).

GE Link bulb philipshuelux tcpconnected
GE Link Philips Hue Lux TCP Connected
Price* $14.97 $29.97 $19.97
Lumens 800 750 800
Watts 12 9 11
Weight 175g 133g 179g
Lens Clear plastic Translucent glass Translucent plastic
Available at** Home Depot Apple Store, Best Buy, Home Depot, Staples Home Depot
Works with Wink, Link, SmartThings, Revolv Hue, Wink, SmartThings, Revolv, pēq, Staples Connect TCP Gateway, Wink, SmartThings
Protocol(s) ZigBee ZigBee, IP (via hub) 6LoWPAN
Comments Clear globe exposes lighting diodes, making bulb glarey Looks identical to Philips’ standard soft white A19 LED bulb (432914) All 3rd party services require the TCP Gateway for integration

*Prices are shown as listed at Home Depot.
**Retail outlets listed for US only.

Of the products considered here, the TCP Connected and Philips Hue Lux bulbs cast the warmest, even light. Home Depot and GE received lots of attention with the announcement of a sub-$15 entrant in this space, but the GE Link seems first gen and could use some iterative refinement. At nearly $30 (already $10 lower than their originally announced retail price), Philips may have priced themselves out of this competition, particularly considering the quality of and increasing support for TCP’s offering. Meanwhile, we know that LG, Samsung, Belkin, and possibly CREE may be on these manufacturers’ heels with offerings of their own soon.

Updated 2/17/2015: Noted Revolv’s support for GE Link and pēq’s support for Hue Lux

Also check out our comparison of some newer connected bulbs: WeMo, Cree Connected, and LG Wireless

Sponsor